Luxury Resorts in the Caribbean: Choosing the Island Before the Resort

Five islands, five kinds of stay, and a season that shapes the week as much as the resort does

About Luxury Resorts in the Caribbean

The Caribbean is not one destination. It is a chain of islands, each with its own way of arriving, its own beaches, and its own pace, so the island is the first decision and the resort is the second. The Caribbean luxury resorts in this guide are grouped by island for that reason: St Barths, Anguilla, Turks and Caicos, Barbados, and Antigua.

Each resort below is described as it presents itself on its own website. Some island hotels close for part of the autumn, so opening dates are worth confirming before anything else. For beaches across the world, see our guide to luxury beach resorts; this page goes deeper into the Caribbean.

A Caribbean stay, planned around the island you prefer

Caribbean Luxury Resorts: St Barths and Anguilla

St Barths is small and French, and it has no direct long-haul flights. The island’s tourist office explains that most travellers connect through Saint Martin, Guadeloupe, Antigua, or Puerto Rico, and then take a short flight or a ferry. Le Barthélemy Hotel & Spa sits on a crescent bay at Grand Cul-de-Sac, with interiors by designer Sybille de Margerie and a spa by Augustinus Bader. Hotel Manapany is on the beach at Anse des Cayes, with 43 rooms, suites, and villas, and it describes its style as barefoot luxury.

Anguilla has a different character, and its tourist board calls it the culinary capital of the Caribbean. Four Seasons Resort and Residences Anguilla spans 35 acres on the northwest shore, between Barnes Bay and Meads Bay, and offers villas as well as rooms. Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club, on Rendezvous Bay and Merrywing Bay, has a different character: it combines two beaches with golf, a spa, and a family waterpark, and presents its stay as all-inclusive. Anguilla’s Clayton J. Lloyd Airport takes small to medium aircraft, including most corporate jets, and ferries from Saint Martin arrive at Blowing Point.

Gustavia harbour in St Barths at sunset with yachts moored below red-roofed houses and cactus in the foreground

Turks and Caicos, Barbados, and Antigua

Guests often begin with 5 star resorts in the Caribbean, yet a rating says little about the setting, and the best Caribbean resorts are not always the largest. In Turks and Caicos, COMO Parrot Cay is a private island retreat of 1,000 acres, edged by four miles of white sand, with beach villas and the COMO Shambhala wellness offer. The transfer from Providenciales airport takes about 50 minutes, a 15-minute drive followed by a 35-minute boat ride, so it suits a stay in which arriving is part of leaving the world behind.

In Barbados, this guide looks at the calm west coast. Cobblers Cove, in Speightstown, is a family-owned hotel of 40 suites with verandas that look over the sea and the gardens, and it is known for island-inspired cooking. The Barbados tourist board describes two main seasons: a dry season through the northern winter and spring, and a wetter, warmer season through the summer and autumn.

Antigua suits a week with several beaches in reach. Curtain Bluff stands on a rocky promontory on the south side of the island, with 72 suites and guest rooms on or near the sand, and the resort says meals and most activities are included in the room rate. The tourist board lists non-stop flights from Canada, the United States, the United Kingdom, and Germany.

Arrange It With Perfect.Live

Tell us the dates and the island you prefer, and we will arrange the stay

Where to Start

  • Choose the island first. St Barths suits a small, French-style week, Anguilla suits beaches and dining, Turks and Caicos suits privacy, Barbados suits a calm west coast, and Antigua suits several beaches
  • Decide how much of the island you want. A private island suits a week without leaving, while a larger resort suits guests who want golf, a waterpark, or more than one restaurant
  • Check the way in. Some islands need a connecting flight, a ferry, or a boat, so see our guide to VIP airport assistance for how we arrange the airport side
  • Consider flying privately. Anguilla’s airport takes most corporate jets, and our guide to private jet charter versus first class explains how to think about the choice
  • Add the sea. Many guests pair a resort week with a few days under sail, and our guide to a yacht charter in the Caribbean covers the regions and the season
Sailboats anchored in a sheltered Antigua bay below green hills in warm golden-hour light

Choosing the Season and the Way In

The National Hurricane Center states that the Atlantic hurricane season runs from 1 June to 30 November, and that the Atlantic basin includes the Caribbean Sea. It places the peak of the season on 10 September, with most activity from mid-August to mid-October. A week in the Caribbean is therefore easiest to plan outside those months, and the weeks in between are worth a check close to the dates.

Rainfall differs by island as well. Anguilla’s tourist board gives September and October as the usual rainy months and February and March as the driest. Resorts publish their own opening and closing dates, so we confirm them before a stay is fixed.

For the winter months, our guide to winter sun destinations compares the Caribbean with other warm places. For a summer plan, see our list of the best luxury summer resorts in 2026. For other coasts, see our guides to luxury resorts in Hawaii and luxury resorts in Mexico.

How We Help

At Perfect.Live, we choose the island with you and then the resort, from the Caribbean luxury resorts open on your dates. We compare the settings and the rooms, request the room types that suit the stay, and arrange the transfers, the flights, and the dinners around it, with one point of contact for the whole trip. We plan the days and look for availability where it is available, and we suggest alternatives if a resort is full.

Frequently Asked Questions

It depends on the island, so we start with the kind of week you want. Le Barthélemy Hotel & Spa in St Barths, Four Seasons Resort and Residences Anguilla, and Cobblers Cove in Barbados are three different starting points

Look at the setting, the service, and how the resort suits your plans, and not only at the rating. A star rating is a single measure, and we compare rooms, beaches, dining, and arrival before we suggest a stay

The National Hurricane Center states that the Atlantic hurricane season runs from 1 June to 30 November, with the peak on 10 September. We plan stays with that calendar in mind

St Barths has no direct long-haul flights, and most travellers connect through Saint Martin, Guadeloupe, Antigua, or Puerto Rico before a short flight or a ferry. We arrange the connections as one plan

As soon as the dates are fixed, and earlier for school holidays and the festive season. We look for availability on your dates and suggest alternatives if a resort is full

Ready When You Are

We don’t just save time. We create it

More to Explore